Thomas A. Guerriero PhD’s case commentary on Kadrey v. Meta Platforms: A.I. Training and Market Harm to Authors looks at a fair use ruling that Meta won, and at why the court was careful to say the decision does not stand for the proposition that the use was lawful. The summary, the citation and a link to the original order are on the case commentary page.
Independent commentary by a non-attorney, for educational purposes only. Not legal advice.
Why market evidence decided the case
The commentary examines Kadrey v. Meta Platforms, Inc., No. 3:23-cv-03417-VC, Order on Cross-Motions for Partial Summary Judgment, slip op. (N.D. Cal. June 25, 2025) (Chhabria, J.). Meta was granted partial summary judgment on fair use against thirteen authors whose books were used to train its Llama models. Thomas A. Guerriero PhD focuses on the court’s emphasis that the result turned on the authors’ failure to present evidence, and on why the fourth fair use factor decided the case on this record.
The court considered three theories of market harm: regurgitation, a lost licensing market and market dilution. It called market dilution the “potentially winning argument”, and found the authors had presented no meaningful evidence on it.
A contrast, and later history
The commentary compares this approach with Bartz v. Anthropic, decided two days earlier in the same court. It also records later history, including the DMCA ruling, the March 2026 amendment order and an October 2026 discovery order. It does not state any outcome on the distribution or contributory infringement claims.
For authors and organisations that hold rights in written works, the practical lesson is that the strength of a challenge to AI training may depend on evidence of how AI outputs actually affect demand for the original works. The commentary is not advice about any particular use of data, and it was not filed with any court.
Read the full summary and the PDF on the Kadrey v. Meta commentary page. More work is collected on the main hub, ThomasGuerriero.com.
Don’t get left behind. Chase greatness.
Related reading
If you want help growing your business, team, or just want to pursue greatness yourself, book a free 15 minute call at the link below.




